Search

Search Results

• 1. [Article] Contemporary regional forest dynamics in the Pacific Northwest

  Recent climatic warming trends and increases in the frequency and extent of wildfires have prompted much concern regarding the potential for rapid change in the structure and function of forested ecosystems ...

  Citation × Citation Citation Abstract Copy Title: Contemporary regional forest dynamics in the Pacific Northwest Author: Reilly, Matthew J. (Matthew Justin), 1975- Recent climatic warming trends and increases in the frequency and extent of wildfires have prompted much concern regarding the potential for rapid change in the structure and function of forested ecosystems around the world. Episodes of mortality in wildfires and insect outbreaks associated with drought have affected large areas and altered landscapes, but little is known about the cumulative effects of these disturbances at the regional scales. I used data from two different forest inventories in the Pacific Northwest to develop a framework for tracking regional forest dynamics and examine variation in tree mortality rates among vegetation zones that differ in biophysical setting as well as recent and historical disturbance regimes. In the second chapter I developed an empirically based framework for tracking regional forest dynamics using regional inventory data collected from 2001 to 2010. I characterized the major dimensions of forest structure and developed a classification incorporating multiple attributes of forest structure including biomass, size, and density of live trees, the distribution and abundance of dead wood, and the cover of understory vegetation. A single dimension related to live tree biomass accounted for almost half of the variation in a principal components analysis of structural attributes, but dimensions related to density and size of live trees, dead wood, and understory vegetation accounted for as much additional variation. Snags and biomass of dead and downed wood were related to multiple dimensions while understory vegetation acted independent of other dimensions. Results indicated that structural development is more complex than a monotonic accumulation of live biomass and that some components act independently or emerge at multiple stages of structural development. The hierarchical classification reduced the data into three “groups” based on live tree biomass, followed by eleven "classes" that varied in density and size of live trees, and finally twenty-five structural types that differed further in the abundance of dead wood and cover of understory vegetation. Most structural types were geographically widespread but varied in age of dominant trees by vegetation zone indicating that similar structural conditions developed in environments with different biophysical setting, climate, and disturbance/successional histories. Low live biomass structural types (<25 Mg/ha) differed in live tree density and the abundance of live and dead legacies, demonstrating that the variation in early developmental stages depends on the rate of tree establishment and the nature and severity of recent disturbance. Forests in early developmental stages made up less than 20% of most vegetation zones and diverse types with live or dead legacies associated with wildfires were rare. Moderate live biomass structural types (25-99 Mg/ha) represented multiple mid, mature, and late developmental stages, some of which lack analogs in existing conceptual models of structural development such as lower density woodlands with big trees. These structural types included two that have high densities of snags indicative of recent episodes of mortality; together these made up as much as 10% of some dry vegetation zones. Several high live biomass structural types (100->300 Mg/ha) were identified and substantiated the diversity and relative dominance of mature and later developmental stages, particularly in wet vegetation zones. The relative abundance and make up of structural types varied widely by vegetation zone. Most forests in wet vegetation zones had moderate to high live biomass and were in mid and mature developmental stages, while diverse early developmental stage stages were extremely rare. Dry forests had a far greater range of variation in the relative abundance of structural types which is partially attributable to the greater range of climatic conditions they included, but also to the occurrence of recent episodes of mortality associated with wildfires and insects. In the third chapter I examined variation in tree mortality rates using a different regional inventory that occurred from the mid-1990s to the mid-2000s. I compared the distribution of rates among stands in different vegetation zones and stages of structural developmental. I developed a simple framework based on changes in live tree density and mean tree size and examined trends in structural change associated with disturbances at different levels of mortality across all stages of structural development. Most plots were within the range of "background" mortality rates reported in other studies (<1.0 %/yr) and extremely high "stand-replacing" levels of mortality (>25%/yr) were rare. Approximately 30% of plot mortality rates occurred at intermediate levels (>1%/yr and <25%/yr) as result of insects and fire, highlighting the importance of conceptualizing mortality as a continuum as opposed to just “background” or “stand-replacement” to fully represent dynamics at a regional scale. The distributions of mortality differed among many vegetation zones. Levels of mortality were primarily <2.5%/yr in western hemlock, silver fir, and mountain hemlock vegetation zones where fires were rare and insects and pathogens occurred predominantly at endemic levels. Rates were highest in subalpine forests and higher elevation grand fir and Douglas-fir forests as a result of fire and insects. Mortality rates in ponderosa pine, the hottest driest forest vegetation zone, were surprisingly low, and there was little to no mortality in plots with no evidence of disturbance. Mortality rates varied among developmental stages in all vegetation zones but few consistent patterns emerged. Levels of mortality were often lowest in early developmental stages but varied in later stages where they were lowest in wet vegetation zones and highest in subalpine and dry vegetation zones. Application of a simple framework indicated that multiple trajectories of structural change were common at levels of mortality <2.5%/yr, but structural change at higher levels was predominantly associated with a “thinning” trajectory defined by decreases in density and increases in mean tree size. Results indicated that the rate and magnitude of mortality related change during the study period varies widely across the region. Rapid change has occurred in subalpine, grand fir/white fir, Douglas-fir, and ponderosa pine vegetation zones where disturbances such as insects and fire were widespread. However, these disturbances have potentially restored some aspects of historical structure by reducing overall density and increasing the dominance of bigger trees. In western hemlock, silver fir, and mountain hemlock vegetation zones where higher levels of mortality related to disturbances were rare, wildfires have increased landscape diversity by creating diverse early successional habitats and most change was more subtle but may be manifest oevr longer periods if current trends continue. This examination of short-period mortality rates and associated structural change across a broad geographic provides context for understanding trends from localized studies and potential ecological consequences of mortality, but there is still a great deal of uncertainty as to how the effects of a changing climate and disturbance regimes will manifest themselves over longer time scales. This dissertation is one of the first field based assessments of recent forest dynamics at a regional scale. The results of both chapters, each based on a different dataset, told a similar story. The abundance of structural types in various vegetation zones estimated during the mid-2000s was consistent with the cumulative effects of tree mortality during the preceding decade. It was evident that wildfire effects and recent mortality were small relative to the regional extent of the study and have contributed to structural diversity and restoration of historic structure in stands where fire exclusion and past logging has increased total stand density and decreased the dominance of big trees. However, the rate of change and cumulative effects of recent forest dynamics varied widely by geographic location and vegetation zone and there was greater variability and uncertainty regarding the effects of mortality at smaller landscape scales where individual events like large wildfires have the potential to rapidly alter the landscape structure and composition. Assessing this variability and the scales at which trade-offs (e.g. losses of old-growth and creation of diverse early developmental stages) occur will be an important next step in understanding the cumulative ecological effects of recent wildfires and tree mortality on Pacific Northwest forests. Title: Contemporary regional forest dynamics in the Pacific Northwest Author: Reilly, Matthew J. (Matthew Justin), 1975- Recent climatic warming trends and increases in the frequency and extent of wildfires have prompted much concern regarding the potential for rapid change in the structure and function of forested ecosystems around the world. Episodes of mortality in wildfires and insect outbreaks associated with drought have affected large areas and altered landscapes, but little is known about the cumulative effects of these disturbances at the regional scales. I used data from two different forest inventories in the Pacific Northwest to develop a framework for tracking regional forest dynamics and examine variation in tree mortality rates among vegetation zones that differ in biophysical setting as well as recent and historical disturbance regimes. In the second chapter I developed an empirically based framework for tracking regional forest dynamics using regional inventory data collected from 2001 to 2010. I characterized the major dimensions of forest structure and developed a classification incorporating multiple attributes of forest structure including biomass, size, and density of live trees, the distribution and abundance of dead wood, and the cover of understory vegetation. A single dimension related to live tree biomass accounted for almost half of the variation in a principal components analysis of structural attributes, but dimensions related to density and size of live trees, dead wood, and understory vegetation accounted for as much additional variation. Snags and biomass of dead and downed wood were related to multiple dimensions while understory vegetation acted independent of other dimensions. Results indicated that structural development is more complex than a monotonic accumulation of live biomass and that some components act independently or emerge at multiple stages of structural development. The hierarchical classification reduced the data into three “groups” based on live tree biomass, followed by eleven "classes" that varied in density and size of live trees, and finally twenty-five structural types that differed further in the abundance of dead wood and cover of understory vegetation. Most structural types were geographically widespread but varied in age of dominant trees by vegetation zone indicating that similar structural conditions developed in environments with different biophysical setting, climate, and disturbance/successional histories. Low live biomass structural types (<25 Mg/ha) differed in live tree density and the abundance of live and dead legacies, demonstrating that the variation in early developmental stages depends on the rate of tree establishment and the nature and severity of recent disturbance. Forests in early developmental stages made up less than 20% of most vegetation zones and diverse types with live or dead legacies associated with wildfires were rare. Moderate live biomass structural types (25-99 Mg/ha) represented multiple mid, mature, and late developmental stages, some of which lack analogs in existing conceptual models of structural development such as lower density woodlands with big trees. These structural types included two that have high densities of snags indicative of recent episodes of mortality; together these made up as much as 10% of some dry vegetation zones. Several high live biomass structural types (100->300 Mg/ha) were identified and substantiated the diversity and relative dominance of mature and later developmental stages, particularly in wet vegetation zones. The relative abundance and make up of structural types varied widely by vegetation zone. Most forests in wet vegetation zones had moderate to high live biomass and were in mid and mature developmental stages, while diverse early developmental stage stages were extremely rare. Dry forests had a far greater range of variation in the relative abundance of structural types which is partially attributable to the greater range of climatic conditions they included, but also to the occurrence of recent episodes of mortality associated with wildfires and insects. In the third chapter I examined variation in tree mortality rates using a different regional inventory that occurred from the mid-1990s to the mid-2000s. I compared the distribution of rates among stands in different vegetation zones and stages of structural developmental. I developed a simple framework based on changes in live tree density and mean tree size and examined trends in structural change associated with disturbances at different levels of mortality across all stages of structural development. Most plots were within the range of "background" mortality rates reported in other studies (<1.0 %/yr) and extremely high "stand-replacing" levels of mortality (>25%/yr) were rare. Approximately 30% of plot mortality rates occurred at intermediate levels (>1%/yr and <25%/yr) as result of insects and fire, highlighting the importance of conceptualizing mortality as a continuum as opposed to just “background” or “stand-replacement” to fully represent dynamics at a regional scale. The distributions of mortality differed among many vegetation zones. Levels of mortality were primarily <2.5%/yr in western hemlock, silver fir, and mountain hemlock vegetation zones where fires were rare and insects and pathogens occurred predominantly at endemic levels. Rates were highest in subalpine forests and higher elevation grand fir and Douglas-fir forests as a result of fire and insects. Mortality rates in ponderosa pine, the hottest driest forest vegetation zone, were surprisingly low, and there was little to no mortality in plots with no evidence of disturbance. Mortality rates varied among developmental stages in all vegetation zones but few consistent patterns emerged. Levels of mortality were often lowest in early developmental stages but varied in later stages where they were lowest in wet vegetation zones and highest in subalpine and dry vegetation zones. Application of a simple framework indicated that multiple trajectories of structural change were common at levels of mortality <2.5%/yr, but structural change at higher levels was predominantly associated with a “thinning” trajectory defined by decreases in density and increases in mean tree size. Results indicated that the rate and magnitude of mortality related change during the study period varies widely across the region. Rapid change has occurred in subalpine, grand fir/white fir, Douglas-fir, and ponderosa pine vegetation zones where disturbances such as insects and fire were widespread. However, these disturbances have potentially restored some aspects of historical structure by reducing overall density and increasing the dominance of bigger trees. In western hemlock, silver fir, and mountain hemlock vegetation zones where higher levels of mortality related to disturbances were rare, wildfires have increased landscape diversity by creating diverse early successional habitats and most change was more subtle but may be manifest oevr longer periods if current trends continue. This examination of short-period mortality rates and associated structural change across a broad geographic provides context for understanding trends from localized studies and potential ecological consequences of mortality, but there is still a great deal of uncertainty as to how the effects of a changing climate and disturbance regimes will manifest themselves over longer time scales. This dissertation is one of the first field based assessments of recent forest dynamics at a regional scale. The results of both chapters, each based on a different dataset, told a similar story. The abundance of structural types in various vegetation zones estimated during the mid-2000s was consistent with the cumulative effects of tree mortality during the preceding decade. It was evident that wildfire effects and recent mortality were small relative to the regional extent of the study and have contributed to structural diversity and restoration of historic structure in stands where fire exclusion and past logging has increased total stand density and decreased the dominance of big trees. However, the rate of change and cumulative effects of recent forest dynamics varied widely by geographic location and vegetation zone and there was greater variability and uncertainty regarding the effects of mortality at smaller landscape scales where individual events like large wildfires have the potential to rapidly alter the landscape structure and composition. Assessing this variability and the scales at which trade-offs (e.g. losses of old-growth and creation of diverse early developmental stages) occur will be an important next step in understanding the cumulative ecological effects of recent wildfires and tree mortality on Pacific Northwest forests. Close